This week at Beyond the Box Score I have an article about pitchers’ performance as hitters. For the most part pitchers cannot hit and represent an automatic out in National League (NL) lineups. But there are a few cases of pitchers who succeed when standing in the batter’s box. Two that stand out in today’s game are Madison Bumgarner of the San Francisco Giants and Zack Greinke of the Los Angeles Dodgers. These two also happen to be elite level pitchers, so they really present a more complete package to their teams than other top pitchers. With the statistics presently available we can determine how much value pitchers are adding (or subtracting) on the offensive side of things. In a few cases, like for the two mentioned above, it has a substantial effect. Considering this value shakes up the rankings a bit.
I should note that I don’t think we should take these few examples of pitchers that hit decently as evidence against implementing the designated hitter in the NL. Doing so is a rule change that I think is overdue and should be implemented as soon as possible. Generally, fans are watching baseball to see people who are the best in the world at the game, or at least parts of the game. With that in mind, sending a player who can actually do some damage while at the plate (i.e., a designated hitter), instead of someone who is just doing it because he has to (i.e., most pitchers) will be better for the game.
My article does not focus on the DH in the NL issue, I just felt I would bring it up here. Rather, my article is more of a fun look at Madison Bumgarner’s hitting ability. Check it out: Madison Bumgarner is more than just a great pitcher.